TN-5 · The xAI files · A game with receipts
Real talk about data centers.
So how’d you do?
0 of 35What did we learn
The real issues aren’t the loudest ones.
Nobody is draining the aquifer dry. AI is not using half the grid. Thousands of jobs were never coming. The scary version and the rosy version are both wrong.
What’s real: a company ran around 35 unpermitted gas turbines next to a neighborhood that was already sick. The recycled-water plant that was supposed to fix the aquifer draw is on indefinite pause. Nobody you vote for controls where your power comes from. Tennessee has almost no rules for industrial water withdrawals. And Memphis has no law about how police use AI on you.
Each fix sits in a different office. That’s how everybody gets to point at somebody else. Here’s who holds each lever.
City and county
Most of the power is local.
- The Shelby County Health Department issues the air permits. It can require the strictest pollution controls and real-time public monitoring, and enforce against anyone operating without a permit.
- MLGW’s board can make power deals public and require big users to power down during peak hours and pay their own infrastructure costs.
- The city council can write a data center noise law like Chandler, Arizona did, pass a surveillance oversight ordinance like Oakland did, and put clawbacks in any future incentive deal.
State
Tennessee has the authority. It isn’t using it.
- The state could pass real rules for large water withdrawals. Right now it barely has any.
- The legislature could set siting standards for giant power users, so the next Colossus doesn’t land unannounced.
- TDEC could close the “temporary” generation loophole in state permitting for good.
Federal
One House member can’t fix this alone.
- A House member can’t issue permits or order the EPA around.
- What one member can do: demand investigations, drag agencies into hearings, and write bills. Disclosure rules for data center water and power use. Closing the turbine loophole in federal law. Making data centers pay full freight for the grid they use.
- TVA answers to a presidentially appointed board, not to voters. But House committees can haul TVA in to testify and question every deal it makes. I’d treat that as a job requirement.
If you don’t want a data center in your town, the time to fight it is before it gets built. Memphis never got that fight - the deal was negotiated under NDAs and announced as done. Everything on this page - the permits, the water, the bills, the noise, the cameras - is what playing catch-up looks like.
Stay on it
Want to keep up with stories like this that actually matter?
This is the kind of thing I write about every day - Tennessee politics, who holds the levers, and who’s getting played. Sign up for my Substack and it lands in your inbox.